Australia's eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman-Grant has rejected the practicality of a know your customer-type ID verification requirement for social media companies to ensure the age of their users. Addressing Senate Inman-Grant said such a regime
works in the banking industry as it has been heavily regulated for many years, particularly around anti-money laundering: It would be very challenging, I would think, for Facebook for example to re-identify -- or
identify -- its 2.7 billion users, she said. How do they practically go back and do that and part of this has to do with how the internet is architected.
While she admitted it was not impossible, she said it would create a range of
other issues and that removing the ability for anonymity or to use a pseudonym is unlikely to deter cyberbullying and the like. Similarly, she said, if the social media sites were to implement a real names policy, it wouldn't be effective given the way
the systems are set up. She added: I would also suspect there would be huge civil libertarian pushback in the US. I think there are incremental steps we could make, I think totally getting rid
of anonymity or even [the use of] pseudonyms on the internet is going to be a very hard thing to achieve. I want to be pragmatic here about what's in the realm of the possible, it would be great if everyone had a name tag online
so they couldn't do things without [consequence].
|