The
government forced through the controversial digital economy bill with the aid of
the Conservative party last night, attaining a crucial third reading - which
means it will get royal assent and become law - after just two hours of debate
in the Commons.
But despite opposition from the Liberal Democrats and a number of
Labour MPs who spoke up against measures contained in the bill and put
down a number of proposed amendments, the government easily won two
votes to determine the content of the bill and its passage through the
committee stage without making any changes it had not already agreed.
Tom Watson, the former Cabinet Office minister who resigned in
mid-2009, voted against the government for the first time in the final
vote to take the bill to a third reading. However the vote was
overwhelmingly in the government's favour, which it won by 189 votes to
47.
Earlier the government removed its proposed clause 18, which could
have given it sweeping powers to block sites, but replaced it with an
amendment to clause 8 of the bill. The new clause allows the secretary
of state for business to order the blocking of a location on the
internet which the court is satisfied has been, is being or is likely to
be used for or in connection with an activity that infringes copyright.
The Labour MP John Hemming protested that this could mean the
blocking of the whistleblower site Wikileaks, which carries only
copyrighted work. Stephen Timms for the government said that it would
not want to see the clause used to restrict freedom of speech - but gave
no assurance that sites like Wikileaks would not be blocked.
Don Foster, the Liberal Democrats' spokesman for culture, media and
sport, protested that the clause was too wide-ranging: it could apply
to Google, he complained, adding that its inclusion of the phrase
about likely to be used meant that a site could be blocked on its
assumed intentions rather than its actions.
Video game censorship is now set to migrate from the BBFC to the
Video Standards Council (VSC) using European-wide PEGI ratings.
|