In a bizarre example of political correctness being taken to extremes, an Oxford sex shop renewal is being caught up in the conviction of a gang of child abusers in the so called Bullfinch Trial. It is politically incorrect to mention the important
correlation that, in common with, several other cases, the perpetrators were primarily muslims of Pakistani origin. Society has taken the view that such correlations should be played down so as not suggest that millions of other perfectly law abiding
citizens from the same cultural background are unfairly associated with the criminality.
All very civilised, but somehow the same politeness is not accorded accorded to people who trade in, or simply enjoy adult entertainment. Then newspapers,
politicians, or anyone else with a pet morality to peddle, is encouraged to make up bollox about sexual entertainment turning men into rapists or whatever. It matters not a jot that they defaming millions of totally innocent people, it matters not a jot
that scientists and researchers have found next to nothing to support any such causality, and it matters not a jot that there are millions of porn viewers who are perfectly law abiding citizens.
Now in Oxford, reprehensible politicians are
highlighting the Bullfinch case as reasons for opposing the sex shop licence renewal for the Private Shop in Cowley Road. The locality became linked to the case when trial barrister Lee Karu mentioned that one of the rapists was brought up on the Cowley
Road.
Green councillor Dick Wolff said residents had contacted him objecting to the licence renewal saying:
The residents are objecting and I am representing those views. (Those views) are based on Bullfinch.
Green councillor Greg Simmons said:
The Bullfinch inquiry highlighted that the environs of the Cowley Road are a contributing factor and although it's not to do with the sex shop itself, it is
contributing to the gritty sub-culture of the Cowley Road and so that is what convinced me (to object).
Green councillor Elise Benjamin said:
My feeling is that with Bullfinch there has been more
concern, especially with Mr Karu's comment about Cowley Road.
Its not as if the church hasn't got deep troubles with child abuse. But it doesn't seem very grateful for the political correctness that generally cushions religion against
criticism and unfair generalisations about clerical child abuse. And it seems that the church is quick to make equally unfair aspersions about other people.
Bruce Gillingham, rector of St Clement's Church said:
We're bound to look at things differently in the light of the Bullfinch trial, it's certainly caused concern. We want to see the spirit and the ethos of Cowley road raised so that all people feel welcome.
The local MP has wisely opted not to get too involved in the debate and has taken up his position on the fence. Oxford East MP Andrew Smith said that he supported the Cowley residents who wanted to avoid giving the area a seedy
image , but that the shop and its customers also have rights .
The police have not objected to the licence renewal, and the application will be considered by Oxford City Council on 20th August.
Update:
Resident's association that doesn't consult the residents
20th August 2013. See article from
oxfordmail.co.uk
A former councillor has made a few relevant comments about objections to the sex shop licence.
Patrick Gray, who served as a city councillor for the
east and central ward between 1979 and 1990, said it was wrong for objectors to use the Bullfinch child abuse case to oppose the renewal of The Private Shop's licence in Cowley Road.
Ten formal objections were made to the council against the
renewal application submitted in June, including from Green councillors Craig Simmons and Dick Wolff, with many referencing comments made by lawyers in Bullfinch about a sub-culture on Cowley Road.
Grey pointed out:
There is no connection to Bullfinch and the shop is behind closed doors. No evidence has been produced to support the assertion that it was responsible for the terrible crimes revealed by the Bullfinch enquiry.
People have a choice whether they go to the shop or not and we do not want to live in a vigilante society.
Gray added that he was upset to find that the Divinity Road Area Residents' Association (DRARA) had submitted a formal
objection without consulting residents. He is one of the founder members of the residents' association. He said:
Most people who we know in this area take issues of freedom of expression very seriously and would be
deeply concerned by what would amount to censorship. The residents' association ought to consult people.
DRARA chairwoman Elizabeth Mills notable didn't refute the charges and just said:
I am sorry
if anyone thinks we have stepped outside our brief and anyone can step forward to sit on the committee.
Update: Licence Renewed
21st August 2013. See article from
oxfordmail.co.uk
The shop licence has been renewed at a Licensing and Registration Sub Committee meeting at Oxford City Council. Ten written representations were noted.
Update: An insult to everybody who lives in the area
23rd August 2013. See
article from
oxfordmail.co.uk
Those behind a sex shop licence application have said linking it to the Bullfinch child abuse case was an insult to everybody who lives in the area .
Darker Enterprises said the sex shop had no link to the case whatsoever . Management consultant Clive Sullivan, speaking on behalf of the owners, told the committee:
I have gone through the (Bullfinch)
supplement in the Oxford Mail in detail and there is not one reference to a sex shop.
There is a reference of drugs and alcohol being used in respect of grooming unfortunately of girls.
I don't hear people
asking for every premises in Cowley Road selling alcohol to be closed down.
[And lets not even go with the more obvious, but unmentionable, suggestion of asking for all mosques to be closed down].
In the event Oxford Council
committee chairwoman Mary Clarkson said in its 32-year history the shop had caused no problems:
We have heard all the concerns that have been raised but we don't believe there has been a significant change since the
last renewal to not justify renewal.